Louisiana Supreme Court Hears Discipline Case Against Shreveport Judge Sheva Sims

A big feud on the local judicial front. The Louisiana Supreme Court heard arguments in a disciplinary case against Shreveport City Court Judge Sheva Sims. She has been facing several allegations of misconduct and the Louisiana Judiciary Commission has recommended Sims be suspended for one year. But that recommendation is now in the hands of the state's high court. Sims’ defense team asked the justices for a lighter penalty.

Judiciary Commission Details Alleged Misconduct

Sims has been accused of six counts of misconduct. These charges include the use of a court-owned SUV, mistreating some litigants in her court and errors in bond and sentencing guidelines.

Michelle Andrina Beaty represented the Judicial Commission during the hearing and she accused Simes of exhibiting behavior that she described as “black robe-itis.” That is a term used to describe judges who abuse their authority on the bench.

READ MORE: Details about the Sheva Sims Accusations

Sim's attorney Carl Hellmers argued the one year suspension is too harsh. He has asked the state's high court to lower the penalty against his client. Hellmers has suggested a 60-day suspension.

If Sims is suspended for a year, the other Shreveport City Judges Emily Merckle, Brian Barber, Sr. and Brittany Arvie will have to step up to fill the void.

Get our free mobile app

When Is a Ruling Expected in the Sims Case

The Louisiana State Supreme Court is expected to issue a written ruling on this case in the next few weeks. The justices can accept the one year suspension, impose a lighter penalty or possibly remove her from the bench permanently.